Angelic Paranoia

Paranoidangel's Website

The Menagerie
Sunday 5th May 2019 6:05 pm

No Discovery spoilers this time.

I rewatched the Menagerie and realised it's really just a tale of friendships - of Spock and Pike and Spock and Kirk.

Spock plans to take Pike to Talos IV. He has it all worked out with the Talosians to take over the Enterprise and distract Kirk long enough to get Pike there. He tells Pike he has it well-planned and he does. That part at least.

Going to Talos means the death penalty and Spock commits mutiny, which is not exactly going to do much of his career either. Those parts are not so well planned - he pretty much relies on Starfleet feeling sorry for Pike and understanding why Spock does it, once he explains. He is also perhaps relying Kirk putting in a good word for him. He risks a lot for Pike, which speaks to the depth of their relationship.

What makes it interesting, is Kirk's reaction to all this, once it's all been explained. He says:

Mister Spock, even if regulations are explicit, you could have come to me and explained.

Spock says he didn't because he didn't want Kirk to face the death penalty too, which Kirk doesn't get the chance to respond to. But it does tell us that if Spock had gone to Kirk with his plan, Kirk would have helped him. Kirk didn't even know Pike - they only met once. So it speaks a lot for the depth of Kirk and Spock's relationship that Kirk would take on the same risks, just to help his friend help another friend.

Kirk points out at the end that Spock has been very emotional about it all. Of course Spock says it's all logical, but really, it's not. The planning Spock does it logical, but initiating it is entirely out of emotion.


Categories: TV : | | Comments are off for this post | Link

PA Site created by Paranoidangel
Powered by WordPress